As a middle-distance runner for Columbia University, Jacob Caswell didn’t feel like he had the space to be themself.
Because collegiate track and field events only include men’s and women’s divisions, Caswell, who is nonbinary, competed in men’s races. But they said they felt constrained by gender norms as an NCAA athlete, unable to question their gender identity or risk self-expression without risking their place on a team.
Road racing is now creating intentional space for runners like Caswell. In late March, Caswell ran the New York City Half Marathon for a new category of nonbinary runners that included 21 entrants. And on April 24, Caswell entered the Brooklyn Marathon – their first marathon – and broke the tape to win a nonbinary division.
“Being able to not even win but just compete as yourself, it’s just been freeing,” Caswell said.
Over the past year, road races across the United States have debuted a nonbinary category, typically around two dozen or fewer such competitors at each event. Although political debates have led Republican-backed state laws to restrict transgender athletes ‘participation in girls’ and women’s competitions, there has been little discussion about how nonbinary athletes can or should compete in gender-segregated sports.
The nonbinary category races have not drawn much public controversy. Most nonbinary runners go unnoticed on race day, running tens of thousands of other amateur competitors. But for many participants, the ability to select a descriptor more accurate than “male” or “female” when registering for a race makes them feel more visible and respected.
Being around transgender and gender-nonconforming runners, Caswell said, “helps me compete both athletically and live more authentically.”
The small turnouts are reminiscent of women’s marathoning a half-century ago. In 1970, there were about 20 well-known female marathoners in the world, and, in 1972, the Boston Athletic Association, which organizes the Boston Marathon, saw recording women times as “pretty much an experiment.” Later that year, only six women ran the New York City Marathon as its first official racers in the women’s category. The race’s first nonbinary field includes 16 runners in November 2021.
This year’s Brooklyn Marathon and the Half Marathon, organized by the New York City Runs, was the largest nonbinary field to date with 82 finishers in the division.
“I felt a sense of pride seeing that at the very front, just behind us were more nonbinary people – representing and being out and proud at the race,” said Zackary Harris, who placed second in the half-marathon.
For runners, like Harris, who led their fields, the races also offered an opportunity to win prize money.
In September, the Philadelphia Distance Run became the first organization to offer equal prize money to nonbinary athletes. It was an easy decision, said Ross Martinson, one of the event’s organizers. “We want to have a competitive race and get the best nonbinary runners out there,” he explained.
Last week, New York City Runs gave competitors equal payouts in each category. In the marathon, Hirut Guangul won the women’s race with a time of 2 hours 36 minutes and 20 seconds, Aaron Mora won the men’s race in 2:27:46 and Caswell won the nonbinary race in 2:35:17. In the half-marathon, Lily Anderson won the women’s race with a time of 1:18, Teshome Asfaha won the men’s race in 1:01:47 and the Winter Parts won the nonbinary race with a time of 1:12:48. All six runners accepted a cash prize of $ 5,000.
Few major marathons, which invite the world’s fastest athletes to compete, have made these changes welcome nonbinary runners in their amateur ranks, and none have been included in an elite nonbinary field. In March, for example, New York Road Runners offered cash prizes for the top eight amateurs in all three gender categories of the New York City Half Marathon. But since NYRR’s elite divisions are invitational and include only men’s and women’s races, the biggest prize purse – $ 20,000 for top elite finishers – didn’t extend to the nonbinary amateur field.
And while last fall’s New York City Marathon – which included prize purses in the six figures – allowed runners to register as nonbinary, none of the openly nonbinary finishers were eligible for prizes.
Among the efforts at inclusivity, a variety of questions and concerns about equity linger. Gender-nonconforming racers said they felt a lack of recognition for their accomplishments and a lack of attention to their safety and comfort on race day.
Both Caswell and Harris were continually misgendered by race announcers and officials during the Brooklyn Marathon – at the starting line, at the finish and at the awards ceremony. “It was so comically ironic that here we were really trying to celebrate the inclusion of nonbinary runners and they were doing the exact opposite,” Harris said.
Steve Lastoe, the founder of the New York City Runs, acknowledged there was more work to be done. And Caswell is eager to help improve experiences for trans and nonbinary runners. They are now forming a committee with Front Runners, a group for LGBTQ runners, with hopes of collaborating with race organizers to address these and other issues before future events.
“Nonbinary runners have been here this whole time,” Harris said. “We’ve been forced to run in categories that don’t match our gender identities, and now we’re seeing a shift in sports to actually identify us.”